How Should Running Shoes Fit? UK Sizing Guide

How Should Running Shoes Fit? UK Sizing Guide

How should running shoes fit? Leave a thumb's width at the toe, a secure heel and a snug midfoot. Should you size up? Our UK fitting guide explains.

Quick answer: Running shoes should leave about a thumb's width (roughly 1–1.5 cm) between your longest toe and the end of the shoe, hold your heel without slipping, and feel snug but not tight across the midfoot. Most runners go up half a size from their everyday shoe size, because feet swell and move forward over longer runs. If your toes touch the front when you stand up, the shoe is too small.

Fit matters more than brand, cushioning or price. A shoe that is half a size out causes black toenails, blisters and heel rub long before any technology in the midsole makes a difference. Here is how we fit running shoes in the shop, so you can do the same at home.

How much room should you have at the toe?

Aim for a thumb's width, about 1 to 1.5 cm, between the end of your longest toe and the front of the shoe. Check it standing up with your full weight on both feet, not sitting down. Your longest toe is not always your big toe: for plenty of people it is the second toe, so press on the end of the shoe above whichever toe reaches furthest.

That space is there because your foot slides forward slightly with every stride, and more so on downhills. With no gap, your toes hit the front of the shoe thousands of times per run. With too much gap (two thumbs or more), the shoe flexes in the wrong place and your foot moves around inside it.

Should you size up in running shoes?

Usually yes, by half a size. Most runners end up half a size bigger than their everyday shoe or school shoe, and some go a full size up. There are three reasons for this:

  • Feet swell when you run. After 30–40 minutes your feet can be noticeably bigger than when you set off, especially in warm weather.
  • Running socks are thicker than everyday socks, and padded socks take up more room again.
  • Sizing varies by brand. A UK 9 in Hoka is not always the same length as a UK 9 in adidas or On. Go by the fit, not the number on the box.

Do not size up "just in case" with children's shoes. A child's running shoe that is too long rubs at the heel and trips them up. Fit to the foot they have now, with the same thumb-width gap. Our shoe size guide has the conversion tables if you are ordering online.

Width, heel and midfoot: the rest of the fit

Length gets all the attention, but most fit problems we see are about width and heel hold.

Width

Your foot should sit on the platform of the shoe without spilling over the edge, and you should be able to pinch a little of the upper material over the widest part of your foot. If the little toe is pressed against the side, or the upper bulges, try a wide fit rather than going up a size. Going longer to get wider only gives you a shoe that is too long.

Heel

Your heel should feel held, with little or no lift when you walk. A small amount of movement is normal in a brand-new shoe. If it slips noticeably, try lacing through the final eyelet with a heel-lock (runner's loop) before deciding the shoe is wrong.

Midfoot

The middle of the shoe should feel snug and secure, like a firm handshake, but with no pressure points across the top of the foot. If the laces have to be pulled very tight to stop your foot moving, the shoe is too big. If you cannot tighten them without pain on the top of your foot, it is too narrow or too shallow.

How to check fit at home in five minutes

  1. Try them on late in the day, when your feet are at their largest.
  2. Wear the socks you run in. Not your work socks.
  3. Lace them up properly from the bottom eyelet, then stand up and check the thumb-width gap at the toe.
  4. Walk and jog on the spot on a hard floor. Feel for heel slip, rubbing on the little toe and pressure across the top of the foot.
  5. Do the stairs test. Walk down a few steps. If your toes jam into the front, go up half a size.

Keep the shoes indoors and clean while you test them so you can still return them if the fit is wrong.

Signs your running shoes are too small or too big

Too small: black or bruised toenails, numbness in the toes, blisters on the tips of the toes or the side of the little toe, and toes touching the front when standing.

Too big: heel lifting out of the shoe, blisters on the back of the heel, your foot sliding forward on downhills, and having to over-tighten the laces to feel secure.

Your shoes can also stop fitting as they wear. Once the midsole is worn out the shoe loses its shape, which is one of the signs covered in our guide to when to replace running shoes.

Our picks at YC Sports

All in stock online at the time of writing. Check your size on each product page, and come and try them on at the shop if you are between sizes.

Browse the full running shoes range or everything in running. Still deciding what type of shoe you need? Read cushioned vs stability running shoes and road vs trail running shoes.

Frequently asked questions

How should running shoes fit?

Snug at the heel and midfoot, with a thumb's width (about 1–1.5 cm) of space in front of your longest toe and enough room to wiggle your toes. They should feel comfortable from the first run. Running shoes should not need "breaking in".

Is it better for running shoes to be tight or loose?

Neither. The heel and midfoot should be secure, so your foot does not slide, while the toe box should be roomy. Tight toes cause black toenails, and a loose heel causes blisters.

Do I size up or down for running shoes?

Most adults size up by half a size from their everyday shoe, because feet swell during a run. Very few runners need to size down. Always check the toe gap standing up rather than relying on the number.

My running shoes are slightly too big. What should I do?

Try a thicker running sock and a heel-lock lacing first. If your heel still lifts or your foot slides forward, swap down half a size while the shoes are still unworn and returnable.

Should running shoes be the same size as my normal shoes?

Often not. Running shoes are usually half a size bigger than everyday shoes, and sizing varies between brands, so try each new model on rather than assuming your usual size.

Get fitted properly

A size chart gets you close, but trying shoes on gets the fit right. Bring your running socks (and your old shoes, if you have them) and we will help you check length, width and heel hold before you buy. Find us and get in touch, or shop running shoes online with the five-minute home fit check above.

Need a hand choosing?

Our team has been kitting out players, parents, schools and clubs in Cardiff since 1983. Shop our Running Shoes range online, or visit our Whitchurch, Cardiff store and we will help you get it right first time.

Popular picks related to this guide:

Shop Running Shoes →